Gutter Boy
Tim Sherwood
And Gallagher. Then continue to bypass midfield
-
Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara
Leon Goretzka
- Thread starter Surfless
- Start date
It could be a loan to ride out the injury issues we have
K.D.D.D.D.Soc
Nayim
It doesn't matter if we sign anyone or not, some people will be unhappy.
Gutter Boy
Tim Sherwood
We likely wouldnt have enough changes to get him into our CL squad, which has to be a factor on short term punts
why we need to improve in the prem - the players turning up in the CL are doing the job.
He's a good player, experienced, will absolutely bring something, but
- Not the profile we need/are crying out for
- Even moving on Biss and Bentancur would leave you with him, Gallagher and likely Palhinha (can't see us not taking up the option)
- He won't be able to play every game, so rotation option (like Danso, not a bad thing)
If we signed someone of Goretzka's profile (age/experience/ability level) that was just a bit more aligned to the gaps in squad, people absolutely would be happy.
If we sign no one despite the team being in a rut, tons of injuries and us just cashed 43M for making top 4 in CL, people have all the right to be angry
K.D.D.D.D.Soc
Nayim
Do you think we should buy someone even if no one we want is available?
No - we should only be buying players of good quality who will improve us. Most of our players are back around March time, which would mean if we were to purchase players purely just to get numbers in they wouldn't be needed in a month or two time and we can't afford to just waste money like this.
Also why I don't understand why people keep bleating on about how this window will show the owners true ambition. Right now we are 14th, we aren't an attractive option to players of real quality. We tried with Semenyo, and are willing to break our wage structure but as with most players at that level they will have their pick of better teams. And there aren't many big players available in January.
It is in the summer when we are more likely going to be able to show our muscle if that really is the boards intent, getting players in that would really improve us in a January was always unlikely with the predicament we are currently in....
NaijaSpurs
Cecil Poynton
That is not the issue though, we require a progressive passer, which Goetzka is not.
parklane1
Teddy Sheringham
Of course they will, winning on games like football manager[ and the like] makes them all experts.
Bullet
Jimmy Cantrell
That was the huge red flag when they asked Paratici what his preferred style/system was, in a Spurs interview, and he said "Thomas Frank is the manager now so my style/system is whatever he wants, I just match players to what the manager wants and needs"
Er, that is the wrong way round Fabio!
tommysvr
Steve Carr
I agree that some of the complaining goes over the top — mostly on social media, rather than here. But do you think there’s nothing to be upset about as a Spurs fan at the moment?
Is it though? The one thing a DF cannot do is get the coach to change his style or system. That is absolutely a non-starter.
The style issue comes when the manager is chosen - once that happens, any player purchased must align with the manager's wants and needs....
K.D.D.D.D.Soc
Nayim
The problem then is how long are you going to keep your manager, sacking them frequently leaves club with a mishmash of players.
NaijaSpurs
Cecil Poynton
But there is an alternative view that says the DoF develops a strategy to match a club's DNA from the first team to all the teams below.
Then you pick coaches to suit the system. That way you do not pick a coach that plays attacking football and then replace him with a coach that plays defensive football and then says I do not want these players.
If a DoF does his job properly a new coach/manager should not be appointed and then want to change half of the team.
The problem is you have to appoint the right DoF in the first place.
MartyFunkhouser
Steve Sedgley
But good players are good players regardless, the idea we want some lesser LW player (as a random example) because its Frank and not someone else is abit over played as an idea. Yes he didnt want BJ., but let's be frank here, he needs upgrading on longer term.
Xavi is a player for all styles, a CB would be for all styles as would a CF.
Maybe the volume of players change and the one role that does is the CM profile, but beyond that, its the same
Maybe recruitment should be a paired structure... DF+ manager; if the appointment fails, then sack them both...