• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

American politics

I look at the level of scepticism on what science tells us about health to almost the idea that you wouldn't get on a plane because you don't trust the airline or the science or the pilot.

You don’t have to go far to find an example of the scientific consensus, or at least what message gets broadcast to the public, turns out to be completley false and it was actively covered up for financial gain. Opioids in the US is a clear example. The amount of products that were known to cause cancers and it was covered up. Thamaldohide was a big issue in Britain. You can even go back to Cigerettes being promoted as healthy in the 1950’s.
 
Ever is a big word, but yes I would say in my very nonexpert opinion never.

Agreed. And with some level of knowledge (expertise is a big claim for me) I can say the MMR autism link has been thoroughly debunked. There's is literally no correlation or causation when all aspects are considered. And correlation itself has no value until causation is understood.
 
Agreed. And with some level of knowledge (expertise is a big claim for me) I can say the MMR autism link has been thoroughly debunked. There's is literally no correlation or causation when all aspects are considered. And correlation itself has no value until causation is understood.

So not all vaccines ?
 
You don’t have to go far to find an example of the scientific consensus, or at least what message gets broadcast to the public, turns out to be completley false and it was actively covered up for financial gain. Opioids in the US is a clear example. The amount of products that were known to cause cancers and it was covered up. Thamaldohide was a big issue in Britain. You can even go back to Cigerettes being promoted as healthy in the 1950’s.

We should definitely approach anything that someone is making a lot of money from with scepticism, but there's a balancing act of not doing more harm by not taking medication.

Now I have to say that I don't take any medicine that I don't have to take, even painkillers, or any "supplements".
I was vehemently against the mandatory covid vaccine. Due to personal circumstances I took the first vaccination, circumstances that affected my personality, under normal circumstances I would not have taken it.
I don't think my life was ever at serious risk, my life, not saying anyone else was in the same situation.
The lie, and it was a lie that much has been admitted, that the vaccine stopped it spreading meant that me taking the was imho pointless.
Do I think the covid vaccine was dangerous to 99% of the population, no, do I think it has caused adverse reactions in some, yes.
But there are some unfortunate people out there who have reactions to what most of us consider benign substances, it doesn't mean we all will.
 
How would you then explain the expirience my wife had as a pediatric nurse administering vaccines?
Honestly, I can't.
As I say I'm no expert, I giving an opinion, I would also never argue with someone like your wife who not only has that amount of knowledge, experience and who obviously cares as much as she does.
 
We should definitely approach anything that someone is making a lot of money from with scepticism, but there's a balancing act of not doing more harm by not taking medication.

Now I have to say that I don't take any medicine that I don't have to take, even painkillers, or any "supplements".
I was vehemently against the mandatory covid vaccine. Due to personal circumstances I took the first vaccination, circumstances that affected my personality, under normal circumstances I would not have taken it.
I don't think my life was ever at serious risk, my life, not saying anyone else was in the same situation.
The lie, and it was a lie that much has been admitted, that the vaccine stopped it spreading meant that me taking the was imho pointless.
Do I think the covid vaccine was dangerous to 99% of the population, no, do I think it has caused adverse reactions in some, yes.
But there are some unfortunate people out there who have reactions to what most of us consider benign substances, it doesn't mean we all will.

The vaccine slowed the spread down to just about stop the health system from crashing. That then saved lives. I think it was a net positive. While I don't begrudge any vaccine hesitancy that's educated, I do think everyone has to really think hard before not giving their child a measles jab for example.
 
The vaccine slowed the spread down to just about stop the health system from crashing. That then saved lives. I think it was a net positive. While I don't begrudge any vaccine hesitancy that's educated, I do think everyone has to really think hard before not giving their child a measles jab for example.

I know kids get a lot more vaccinations then we got in the 70s, not sure what for not having any kids, but yes I agree, there are certain vaccinations that you really should get.
 
@MartyFunkhouser @thfcsteff

First let me be clear on a few things.
  1. Both my wife and I beleive vaccines to be effective and for the most part do what was intended, in preventing that disease.
  2. Her concern is over the safety of multiple vaccinations, paticuarly at a young age. Yes many of these vaccines have been around for decades, but it’s relatively recent that children are mandated to have 50+ shots.
  3. We do not beleive vaccines are the only cause of Autism or its the only health risk which caused by vaccination.
  4. Getting 6 Covid shots is genuinely mental.

I don’t think the science is close to settled on it being a genetic issue. That’s just where the money for research goes. Even if it is the case, as you point out there would also be pre and post natal conditions that then factor in. My brother and my cousin both have autistic children. No Dr has ever told us if anything we should do differently based on that genetic risk. Both during pregnancy or after. Never even heard an example of that happening to be honest have you?

My belief is that one of those post natal factors which could make a child, who is genetically at a higher risk, is a lack of oxygen flow to the brain. We know that can be caused by vaccination and we also know it’s viewed as a causation of Autism. We also know that vaccines cause seizures and that seizures are associated to Autism. In terms of which end of the spectrum I am really not sure. As I said I really don’t think they should even be classed as the same disorder.

Here is a link to parents speaking about their children developing Autism immediately following a vaccination round. Do you really believe they are all just confused and didn’t realise their children have severe health issues before hand?

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

We can agree to disagree on how close a Nurse is to a Dr. However my wife specifically is as close to being a Dr as a Nurse could be without being one. Has a Masters degree from one of the top Nursing schools in the country along with advanced clinical training. She was fully licensed to diagnose, treat, and prescribe for patients. Spent over a decade working very closely to very close to Drs in practical clinical settings. They administer the treatment and monitor the patient and follow the same standardized evidence-based protocols.

In terms of her specific experiences.

The worst she still feels an enormous amount of guilt over and has nightmares. A perfectly healthy boy who had met all developmental milestones at 18 months. MMR was administered and he almost immediately goes in to seizures which continue to this day. I can remember the phone call I had with her that day and the pain in her voice. The boy was diagnosed as Autistic as far out on the spectrum as you can be. Non verbal. Needs 24/7 care. Can’t go to the toilet by himself. Life has been completely ruined.

She said when she first started internship at a practice the nurses would joke about having to contact VAERS. That it would be a weekly occurrence. She has it documented how many reports she had to file and it was over 250 in an 11 year career. Vaccine injuries were common. Multiple cases of children who had been meeting developmental milestones with no issues who were diagnosed began to show a decline close to vaccination and later diagnosed as Autistic. She says it was more common in boys and in particular African-American boys.

Other health issues that could be tied back to vaccines were more common though. Seizures was one. Developing allergies and gut health issues were the most frequent. Physical issues like toe walking and twitches There was a clear correlation between how young children were when getting vaccines and a negative reaction or ongoing health issue.

The nurses and some of the Drs would discuss it. Most acknowledged there was a problem but there was always a belief that your saving more children that you are harming so you just need to get on with it. But they would all have at least a delayed schedule for their own children. When Covid came along and the mandates came in she said no chance and quit a 11 year career ,which required 6 years of University, where her final annual salary was over $100k.

Went deeper into her research on vaccines and was stunned by the the amount of misleading, and in some cases outright lies about safety measures she was told.

When we was first together and she was going to school and I would do to her family for Thanksgiving/Christmas etc she would have full scale shouting matches with her cousin who was anti vaccine. In every other way she would make Polanski look like Farage that’s how far to the left this cousin is. It used to be a left wing talking point. Now when they see each other it’s “I told you so” and the cousins hates how this has become a MAGA talking point. My wife is to the left on most things as well.

One of her closest friends feels the same. Single Mum so she can’t just quit so she moved to a clinic that is parent choice so almost every child that goes there is unvaccinated. The ones that are will be the older children in that family, usually pre date Covid. She will tell you there is only one unvaccinated child she sees with Autism and he had low oxygen at birth and never met any developmental milestones. No kids with seizures. Food allergies to things like nuts and dairy only in the vaccinated kids. It’s like they are living on a different planet.

We have another friend that’s an elementary school teacher. The unvaccinated kids need to have a medical or religous exemption to overrule the mandates. There used to be maybe 1 kid every few years but it’s usually 1/3 of the class now. She says they rarely get sick. A flu or stomach bug will rip through her class and most of the kids will miss multiple days but never the unvaccinated ones. No allergies or stomach problem. No behavioural issues that would be diagnosed like an ADHD.

Again I am not suggesting, nor does my wife want vaccines to be abolished. She thinks we don’t need so many, that the safety testing is no fit for purpose, and there needs to be significant research in to why some children will have a negative reaction and develop health issues, which includes Autism. Until that happens, she will support politicians that do push for this and she won’t be vaccinating our children.

I appreciate the detailed reply and am sorry for your wife's experience (my brother in law is an emergency doctor and has experienced similar guilt). In a nutshell, it sounds like you and your wife question early childhood vaccination at the rate it currently is and you would both like natural immune systems to be given the chance to grow strong and develop of their own accord. It is a choice for sure.
Your desire for greater research is on point, of course that won't currently be happening in the US where there are significant steps to remove professionals and depts from key areas of the CDC and FDA. So I would say good luck with that.

I will pick you up on your comment that '6 shots is mental'.
I followed the guidelines for my specific situation.
I am happy to have done so. I do not appear any less 'mental' than I was before covid FWIW, and having got it just the once (and lightly) I consider the whole situation to have been a personal win. You wouldn't know the full details of my situation, and I won't be sharing them here, and you are (of course) entitled to your opinion. Just know that you don't know my history and situation, so I'd say that's a two-footer, you missed the ball entirely and fortunately I leapt up to avoid full contact with my shin!
 
Again I’m not saying Big Pharma or Vaccines do not work and cannot be an overall net positive.

I don’t have an issue with these companies making big profits. I have a big chunk in a pharma index fund that’s done amazing.

They should just be safer and that’s to the same level as other medications. And we need to get a better understanding of why some children, and adults have severe adverse reactions to vaccines which can result in long term health issue, which does include Autism even if it may be rare.

The research into autism is relatively new. In overall terms it is still in its infancy and there is still much to understand about it. There are many, many potential factors. Perhaps giving young children the wrong types of food (in terms of processed, etc) can be a trigger for dormant autism. The condition itself sometimes manifest later in life (particularly in high-functioning cases), what triggers that? It is all interesting stuff for sure. My daughter is high-functioning autistic by the way.
 
Ever? Or just not to a point where it should not change how vaccines are currently provided to children?

Let's be honest.
These conditions have been with us for decades, probably centuries. It is only in the last 60 years that people have started to pay attention to them. The 70s and 80s are littered with kids who had ADHD and got smack and sent outside rather than any sort of treatment because as a society we were ignorant. Autistic kids? Come on, they were treated as (and I use this word in context of the era and NOT my own sentiments) 'spazzers' or worse. They were brushed under the carpet largely as 'not normal' (whatever the fudge 'normal' actually means). Those are facts.
It is heart-warming that we finally appreciate and validate these conditions (and depression, anxiety, and so on), but let's not pretend these things did not exist in humanity before vaccines. Again that is not to say that research isn't a great thing, as long as it is done by professionals.
If you could explain to me how Kennedy counts as a professional/expert in the field I'd be interested. I could make a cheap joke at his expense but I'll refrain (for now)...
 
You don’t have to go far to find an example of the scientific consensus, or at least what message gets broadcast to the public, turns out to be completley false and it was actively covered up for financial gain. Opioids in the US is a clear example. The amount of products that were known to cause cancers and it was covered up. Thamaldohide was a big issue in Britain. You can even go back to Cigerettes being promoted as healthy in the 1950’s.

Science and medicine has arguably progressed more in the last 100 years than the 2000 before combined

So going back to 1961 and 1950 is a fair way back, scientifically.

Like I said the other day, life expectancy globally is now through the roof, thats come from science and Healthcare, just like child mortality being at an all time low.

People should be more concerned about how they treat their own bodies than making ridiculous claims against science thats gone on hell of a long way to prolonging life for 100 of millions of people every year
 
I appreciate the detailed reply and am sorry for your wife's experience (my brother in law is an emergency doctor and has experienced similar guilt). In a nutshell, it sounds like you and your wife question early childhood vaccination at the rate it currently is and you would both like natural immune systems to be given the chance to grow strong and develop of their own accord. It is a choice for sure.
Your desire for greater research is on point, of course that won't currently be happening in the US where there are significant steps to remove professionals and depts from key areas of the CDC and FDA. So I would say good luck with that.

I will pick you up on your comment that '6 shots is mental'.
I followed the guidelines for my specific situation.
I am happy to have done so. I do not appear any less 'mental' than I was before covid FWIW, and having got it just the once (and lightly) I consider the whole situation to have been a personal win. You wouldn't know the full details of my situation, and I won't be sharing them here, and you are (of course) entitled to your opinion. Just know that you don't know my history and situation, so I'd say that's a two-footer, you missed the ball entirely and fortunately I leapt up to avoid full contact with my shin!

Food as a trigger is an interesting one as our diet has changed hugely over the last 30 years.
I also think other environmental factors are possible causes, too much screen time way to young, less time outside, less actual physical contact time with others due to smaller families and working mothers.
The changes in our habits over the last few decades have been massive so there's a lot of possibilities.
 
Let's be honest.
These conditions have been with us for decades, probably centuries. It is only in the last 60 years that people have started to pay attention to them. The 70s and 80s are littered with kids who had ADHD and got smack and sent outside rather than any sort of treatment because as a society we were ignorant. Autistic kids? Come on, they were treated as (and I use this word in context of the era and NOT my own sentiments) 'spazzers' or worse. They were brushed under the carpet largely as 'not normal' (whatever the fudge 'normal' actually means). Those are facts.
It is heart-warming that we finally appreciate and validate these conditions (and depression, anxiety, and so on), but let's not pretend these things did not exist in humanity before vaccines. Again that is not to say that research isn't a great thing, as long as it is done by professionals.
If you could explain to me how Kennedy counts as a professional/expert in the field I'd be interested. I could make a cheap joke at his expense but I'll refrain (for now)...

There have been several HHS Secretaries have not had a professional medical background.
 
Science and medicine has arguably progressed more in the last 100 years than the 2000 before combined

So going back to 1961 and 1950 is a fair way back, scientifically.

Like I said the other day, life expectancy globally is now through the roof, thats come from science and Healthcare, just like child mortality being at an all time low.

People should be more concerned about how they treat their own bodies than making ridiculous claims against science thats gone on hell of a long way to prolonging life for 100 of millions of people every year

They still prescribe 100,000 opioids each year.
 
There have been several HHS Secretaries have not had a professional medical background.

That doesn't answer my question.
You've simply made a statement.
Again, can you explain to me how Kennedy counts as a professional/expert in the field? I'm not concerned with the past, I'm asking specifically about one man.
 
That doesn't answer my question.
You've simply made a statement.
Again, can you explain to me how Kennedy counts as a professional/expert in the field? I'm not concerned with the past, I'm asking specifically about one man.

He was nominated for the position by the President and voted in by a senate majority.
 
Back