• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Igor the Interim

I'm more so referring to the earlier part of the season when we picked up more points. At some point that changed. Frank was far from perfect but I think we might have picked up a couple more points than we have since he was removed.

We were also looking a little better and more cohesive just at the point when he was sacked. The results weren't going our way but you could see some improved performances. I do think the Odobert Injury is what finally killed him off.

I actually agree that for a period under Frank we were starting to look more cohesive, like we were understanding more about what he wanted. Maybe around December time.

The issue is the players might have understood it more, but very clearly just didn’t believe in it. The belief went completely. Frank had to go.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Well go and flipping do it then.
Wouldn't it be an interesting experiment to just not have a manager at this moment!

Just a couple of coaches to keep training sessions ticking over but just leave tactics, formation to the team and leadership group. Puts the onus fully on THEM...to pull thru.
 
The numbers don't seem to back up what you're saying but I think it's fairly obvious why. The only 2 players who you would expect to play such passes are Kulu and Maddison and neither has been available this season. I'm not really surprised to see Bentancur, Sarr, Gray, Bergvall, Gallagher and Palhinha failing to make passes they don't really have the ability to play. Why would I expect them to?
@thfcsteff provided numbers from Squawk showing the numbers back it up 100%.
 
@thfcsteff provided numbers from Squawk showing the numbers back it up 100%.
Fernadez's numbers show no difference in through balls though. I don't whose numbers are more accurate, but watching it I don't see any difference. We weren't exactly spamming though balls under Ange, we played the same get it to the wide players have them cross it in football largely, to the lack of effectiveness.

Edit: Well there you go, the numbers confusion has been cleared up. There is actually no difference this or last season in terms of through balls and that was with Kulu and Maddison fit and available for periods.

I would say a deeper issue is that the CM under whichever manager will always be lacking in passing quality because frankly they lack passing quality. If Maddsion or Kulu are available that will massage the situation to some extent as we saw last season but it will still suffer from the same problems which again we saw last season because fundamentally we lack the correct profiles. Add a Nordgaard this season and I feel very certain we would have seen more forward central passes attempted by Frank simply because he would have the player profiles available to do so.
 
Last edited:
A google search has given 5 through balls this season after 29 games (wow!!), whereas last season it was 18.

So heading for about a third this season compared to last if the current pace of 0.17 through balls per game persists.

No idea if the source is accurate but it does without doubt pass the eye test..
 
I suppose the issue with Kudus is the lack of quality depth. Putting aside B Johnson for the moment because he's not capable of playing in the manner Kudus was then we had a squad depth problem whereby Frank simply didn't feel he had an option to rest Kudus. In retrospect Odobert starting shining there so he probably should have tried that earlier but I'll admit that I also didn't like Odobert played on the right anytime I saw him there untill towards the very end of Frank tenure. So yes he probably lying did over play him but he also quite legitimately would not have felt he had any other options.
We went from him feeling like he had no other legitimate options to us having to use the other options for 3 months anyway. A very much both probable and predictable outcome. Short term and rather poor management for me.
 
We weren't capable of it under Ange that's the point. You've actually forgotten what the football was like under Ange last season. At times we were basically the 'Kulu team' if he wants rampaging around we had nothing.

You've even forgotten one of Ange's primary tactics was also playing with width and throwing blind crosses in. There were whole debates here where I said it was a bad tactic and people tried telling me it was the players faults for not being where these blind crosses were going.

I get it you didn't like Frank or the football he played but let's not mythologise and create false narratives. The football under Ange last season was just as awful but just represented slightly differently. This is why I complained about the quality of the players last season, it's why I'm complained about the quality of the players this season.

You need to go back and actually watch the football we played last season, it's not what you're remembering it to be.

The myth of Angeball remains strong.

Wouldn't it be an interesting experiment to just not have a manager at this moment!

Just a couple of coaches to keep training sessions ticking over but just leave tactics, formation to the team and leadership group. Puts the onus fully on THEM...to pull thru.

Said it on here yesterday. Put Romero in charge (or Romero and VDV - although the latter seems to be having some sort of extistential crisis, if the latest quotes are to be believed, so maybe not) as a joint decision maker with Mason or Defoe or A.N. Other with a strong club connection. Nothing then for the players to hide behind.
 
Fernadez's numbers show no difference in through balls though. I don't whose numbers are more accurate, but watching it I don't see any difference. We weren't exactly spamming though balls under Ange, we played the same get it to the wide players have them cross it in football largely, to the lack of effectiveness.

Edit: Well there you go, the numbers confusion has been cleared up. There is actually no difference this or last season in terms of through balls and that was with Kulu and Maddison fit and available for periods.

I would say a deeper issue is that the CM under whichever manager will always be lacking in passing quality because frankly they lack passing quality. If Maddsion or Kulu are available that will massage the situation to some extent as we saw last season but it will still suffer from the same problems which again we saw last season because fundamentally we lack the correct profiles. Add a Nordgaard this season and I feel very certain we would have seen more forward central passes attempted by Frank simply because he would have the player profiles available to do so.
There's no confusion to be cleared up, there is a huge difference in this season and last season with a horrible drop off in through balls this season.


 
We went from him feeling like he had no other legitimate options to us having to use the other options for 3 months anyway. A very much both probable and predictable outcome. Short term and rather poor management for me.
I get that, but realistically would you pick what you consider as a poor option just to do so. Sometimes that works out for the worse. We had that very situation this week when Vicario who many have called to be dropped was so for the weaker backup option and we saw what happened there. The source of the problem is not him not resting Kudus, the source is us not having the depth and breadth of squad where he felt able to rotate Kudus. Until we address these kind of poor squad build issues we will always be plagued with these problems.

Ange did similaer last year when he over played Udogie to the point of injury despite having Reguilion fit and available, yet he did not think Reggie (wrongly imo) was a reasonable rotation option for his first choice, so this isn't a new phenomenon. It always happens when a squad is either unbalanced or weak in terms of quality and depth. We suffer from all of these problems.
 
There's no confusion to be cleared up, there is a huge difference in this season and last season with a horrible drop off in through balls this season.


Thfcsteff the person you first quoted and Fernandez both showed 11 as the number of attempted through balls these season, so there is some confusion with the numbers or different sources are counting differently...

But as I said a difference in numbers isn't exactly shocking when neither Maddison or Kulu have been available all season. Who exactly is supposed to be seeing the gaps and threading passes into those gaps???

I looked it up, on the site you linked Maddison and Kulu were individually responsible for 9 of the through balls we played last season, so exactly half of the entire squad's output. Yet we haven't seen either of them touch a minute on the pitch this season and you wonder why the through ball number might have dropped?
 
Last edited:
Wouldn't it be an interesting experiment to just not have a manager at this moment!

Just a couple of coaches to keep training sessions ticking over but just leave tactics, formation to the team and leadership group. Puts the onus fully on THEM...to pull thru.
Would be interesting to do this. So many of our players seem think they are better than they are … let’s see what they did if they were in charge.

Shame its so risky, otherwise would love it. Either an improvement or a total disaster imo
 
Thfcsteff the person you first quoted and Fernandez both showed 11 as the number of attempted through balls these season, so there is some confusion with the numbers or different sources are counting differently...

But as I said a difference in numbers isn't exactly shocking when neither Maddison or Kulu have been available all season. Who exactly is supposed to be seeing the gaps and threading passes into those gaps???
Xavi Simons for starters. The players that are there are capable of putting in a couple over a season but they aren't even trying.
 
I think the though ball issue is different for each manager.

With Ange, the team was pushed up so there wasn’t as much space in behind, and played a lot of passes to feet. When it worked, especially some of the one touch stuff would open teams up pretty well.

With Frank, he clearly wanted us to get it wide and stick crosses in. This was obvious from every bit of data available to visualise. And the eye test.
 
Xavi Simons for starters. The players that are there are capable of putting in a couple over a season but they aren't even trying.
I don't know how much of Simons you watched before he joined us ( I had and rated him as a player) but there are a few obvious reasons if you know his game well. He mainly plays ahead of the midfield, hes a player who receives the ball deeper in the opposition half, rather than someone who builds from deeper. It means he relies on good quality early passes into him to be most effective, this is an area we absolutely struggle with because we aren't able to play those type of passes. Then, add that he himself is linky, pass and move type. He ideally needs players on the same wavelength as himself to function at his best, we saw it a few times when himself, Odobert and Muani were on the pitch but we rarely saw this enough (a criticism of Frank that is accurate). Then you have to be fair and say Simons has actually attempted load of through balls. we've seen it with our own eyes hes just been incredibly inaccurate and wasteful with them, so its not even a lacking of trying on his part. He has played them, hes just annoyingly played those passes very poorly, is that Frank or Tudor's fault? No, that lies at the feet of the player who is mibricking them.

Regarding our through pass numbers from last year, Kulu and Maddison were directly responsible for 9 of the 18 listed so exactly half. Is it any wonder that the number of through passes has dropped as neither has featured this season?
 
I think the though ball issue is different for each manager.

With Ange, the team was pushed up so there wasn’t as much space in behind, and played a lot of passes to feet. When it worked, especially some of the one touch stuff would open teams up pretty well.

With Frank, he clearly wanted us to get it wide and stick crosses in. This was obvious from every bit of data available to visualise. And the eye test.
Ange also played it mostly with width, albeit with he entire pushed up and compressing the space, leaving no space for inside passes. We then either played it out wide for Johnson to aimlessly cross the ball to no one or ended up passing back to the keeper.

My point is, neither fudging system worked so I don't understand why we keep harking back version 1 that didn't work either. At least hark back to flipping Poch or something, you know a system of play that was actually effective.
 
A google search has given 5 through balls this season after 29 games (wow!!), whereas last season it was 18.

So heading for about a third this season compared to last if the current pace of 0.17 through balls per game persists.

No idea if the source is accurate but it does without doubt pass the eye test..

Perhaps we should've signed Wharton from Blackburn at the same time we activated Phillips' release clause... or stumped up the extra for Fernandes rather of settling for the cheaper Lo Celso... then we might not have ended up in this predicament of having to rely upon a (suspension prone) Centreback as our primary line breaking passer...

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

20260312_160858.jpg
 
Back