I think
@metalgear is moreso trying to say that the quality of the players play and output doesn't match the requirements of the role. I disagree a bit with Maddison as I do think he fits but I agree that ultimately we probably need better than him if we want to say win the league. That's isn't a realistic proposition right now so Mads is fine but we do need real quality competition for him.
Richie I do agree with him, his general play isn't of the required level imo, poor hold up, no runs in behind. Not especially creative, passing is just ok etc. He can do a job but we've seen that Ange doesn't really see him as fist choice. He can do something but yeah I don't think he's the model of striker that Ange actually wants imo.