• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Jamie Donley

Lilbaz said:
Yep. But i think if donley finishes the season with us he will be club trained. Not sure about that though.
Click to expand...
Is it years or seasons? Looks like his birthday is January 3rd. So if it’s years not seasons then he could pass the 3 years early January.
 
Bedfordspurs said:
He can go on loan
he just has to be registered with us
same as Sarr
he is Hg next season
Click to expand...

No sarr is on the b list, because he is u21. Same as veliz and udogie. None will be classed as hg.

Edit (They were u21 when the season started).
 
Bedfordspurs said:
Sarr will be HG for next season
same as Saliba is for arsenal
the rule just says registered so if they go on loan… they are still registered with us
Click to expand...

No. They have to play in that country to be classed hg. A foreign loan means they played abroad.

Same for club trained. The player has to be at the club. It's why devine was kept last season rather than going on loan to a lower league club.
 
Lilbaz said:
No. They have to play in that country to be classed hg. A foreign loan means they played abroad.

Same for club trained. The player has to be at the club. It's why devine was kept last season rather than going on loan to a lower league club.
Click to expand...
Not according to what I’ve just posted
no mention of where they play
 
Lilbaz said:
A quote from your post.

UEFA defines locally-trained or 'homegrown' players as those who, regardless of their nationality, have been trained by their club or by another club in the same national association for at least three years between the age of 15 and 21.

Edit - did you just change your post?
Click to expand...
No
my post is the same
it’s got the same links in it
the Sarr article highlights that arsenal now have Saliba as HG … and his loans are the same as what we did with Sarr
sorry… I did add the links that you quoted

so Sarr will have been trained by us for 3 years at the end of this season
 
Bedfordspurs said:
No
my post is the same
it’s got the same links in it
the Sarr article highlights that arsenal now have Saliba as HG … and his loans are the same as what we did with Sarr
sorry… I did add the links that you quoted

so Sarr will have been trained by us for 3 years at the end of this season
Click to expand...

Thats pl rules though. Uefa are different. At least that's always been the case on football manager.

Pl doesn't have any club trained rules.
 
Lilbaz said:
Thats pl rules though. Uefa are different. At least that's always been the case on football manager.

Pl doesn't have any club trained rules.
Click to expand...
No I’ve posted the rules for europe from UEFA
It doesn’t matter where the player plays just where they are registered

At the end of this season sarr will have been a spurs player for 3 years so is classed as HG and club trained

The rules are almost deliberately vague
 
Last edited:
Bedfordspurs said:
No I’ve posted the rules for europe from UEFA
It doesn’t matter where the player plays just where they are registered

At the end of this season sarr will have been a spurs player for 3 years so is classed as HG and club trained

The rules are almost deliberately vague
Click to expand...

Yes but I can't see anywhere in them that it says you canloan a player abroad and the would still be considered hg. It even says training requires clear definition. But will probably mean 3 years continuous training at the club.

Unless i'm missing something?
 
Lilbaz said:
Yes but I can't see anywhere in them that it says you canloan a player abroad and the would still be considered hg. It even says training requires clear definition. But will probably mean 3 years continuous training at the club.

Unless i'm missing something?
Click to expand...
I think your missing that Arsenal have already done it with Saliba
I posted that article above
No rules about where they play in the published rules
 
Bedfordspurs said:
I think your missing that Arsenal have already done it with Saliba
I posted that article above
No rules about where they play in the published rules
Click to expand...

Seems arsenal cheated. Even though he was loaned out they registered him as a part of their pl squad. So he'd have been considered being in england for 3 seasons. Don't know if that would work for uefa. Or if we did the same with sarr.

www.fourfourtwo.com

Revealed: The ingenious reason Arsenal have included William Saliba in their Premier League squad

The summer signing is back on loan at Saint-Etienne and not even playing for the Gunners this season – but they have a trick up their sleeve
www.fourfourtwo.com www.fourfourtwo.com
 
Lilbaz said:
Seems arsenal cheated. Even though he was loaned out they registered him as a part of their pl squad. So he'd have been considered being in england for 3 seasons. Don't know if that would work for uefa. Or if we did the same with sarr.

www.fourfourtwo.com

Revealed: The ingenious reason Arsenal have included William Saliba in their Premier League squad

The summer signing is back on loan at Saint-Etienne and not even playing for the Gunners this season – but they have a trick up their sleeve
www.fourfourtwo.com www.fourfourtwo.com
Click to expand...
We registered him with us for sure
Hence why the articles say he will be HG
 
There was definitely some reason suggested by people as to why we waited to loan out Devine last season though due to this rule. Who knows maybe they tweaked it recently.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back