When is it acceptable to hit a woman?

[Dayo]

At what point can you use the excuse of self defense or is it a completely no go area?

I'm guessing this isn't one of those times...

[video=youtube;RBV1u0La088]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBV1u0La088[/video]

 

[Mumorn]

Woman want to be treated like equals, right?

 

[BushHillSpurs]

Is it wrong for me to have agreed with what the geezer says and does?
He stated "She wants to act like a man, she can be treated like a man"

Well done to the bus driver. Its about time people in society did something instead of just taking it up the sphcinter with no lube..

 

[DHSF]

I wouldnt punch her the way the bus driver did - no way I can do that. Was brought up never to hit a woman and as im a big guy I couldnt punch her the way that guy did.

However I would grab a woman and wrestle her in order to stop her from hitting me or hitting someone else. If that has to be aggressive then so be it. I mean if a woman had a knife - what you gonna do? not hit her?

 

[Gifter]

Is it wrong for me to have agreed with what the geezer says and does?
He stated "She wants to act like a man, she can be treated like a man"

Well done to the bus driver. Its about time people in society did something instead of just taking it up the sphcinter with no lube..

Your thoughts on this are sick minded IMO, and Mormons.

 

[Gifter]

I wouldnt punch her the way the bus driver did - no way I can do that. Was brought up never to hit a woman and as im a big guy I couldnt punch her the way that guy did.

However I would grab a woman and wrestle her in order to stop her from hitting me or hitting someone else. If that has to be aggressive then so be it. I mean if a woman had a knife - what you gonna do? not hit her?

Did she have a knife? I missed that. Was going to say he could restrain her at worst and remove her.

He hit her with absolute force, was stunned to see it, then seeing the responses just makes me really sad people can think that way.

 

[DHSF]

Did she have a knife? I missed that. Was going to say he could restrain her at worst and remove her.

He hit her with absolute force, was stunned to see it, then seeing the responses just makes me really sad people can think that way.

It was a separate paragraph to discuss a different type of situation - hence the knife part - in answer to the OPs question about 'when is it acceptable to hit a woman'.

 

[linnet_spur]

It would have to be a matter of life or death for me to strike a woman.

 

[Thebarbarian]

Your thoughts on this are sick minded IMO, and Mormons.

Why bring jimmy osmond into the debate ?

Ok , what about if they are part of the Inner Sanctum , or Masons , or they don't digest enough magnesium etc etc etc

The question was When is it acceptable ? Not what you think of their opinion.

 

[Jurgen the German]

It would have to be a matter of life or death for me to strike a woman.

This.

If a woman is attacking you,
that is the only defence for hitting her.

 

[Superhudd]

If she had a weapon, then yes. You do what it takes IMO.

If not then absolutely no, you do as DHSF says, and take down until calm is brought to the preceedings.

 

[Gifter]

Why bring jimmy osmond into the debate ?

The question was When is it acceptable ? Not what you think of their opinion.

No idea what you are talking about in the first line.

Second Line - so, you have the right to question my opinion/response? Yet I not theirs... nice thinking Barbarian, maybe your mind should venture out of the dark ages.

Ok , what about if they are part of the Inner Sanctum , or Masons , or they don't digest enough magnesium etc etc etc

Grow up.

My response was clearly that it is never ok, but if you cannot muster any form of linear thought I apologise for not making it clear to you.

 

[Dayo]

Those that say never, what if a short, thin 7 stone man with glasses came up to you and started giving you brick. Would it be acceptable to hit him? Is not hitting women about a size disadvantage thing or is it purely because they are women?

 

[Gifter]

Those that say never, what if a short, thin 7 stone man with glasses came up to you and started giving you brick. Would it be acceptable to hit him? Is not hitting women about a size disadvantage thing or is it purely because they are women?

Now we get to the meat of it, did someone chin you Dayo?!

 

[Dayo]

No, just wanted an excuse to post that video as I thought it could drum up a bit of a debate.

Never been in a fight in my life and wouldn't consider hitting a woman. I don't wear glasses either.

 

[Gifter]

Twas a joke Dayo, crap one mind.

 

[spooky]

When she's given you a STD. Then you get a tattoo of her bruised face on your neck.

 

[Thebarbarian]

No idea what you are talking about in the first line.

Second Line - so, you have the right to question my opinion/response? Yet I not theirs... nice thinking Barbarian, maybe your mind should venture out of the dark ages.



Grow up.

My response was clearly that it is never ok, but if you cannot muster any form of linear thought I apologise for not making it clear to you.

Mumorn = mumorn , jimmy osmond = Mormon , not hard really .

Please point out where you clearly state it was never ok , as all I see is you denigrating others opinions without actually expressing one yourself.

When you stop telling people to grow up you might actually realise that the question is a good one , ie WHEN is it acceptable . The answer could be never , it could be only when she is on the rags , it may even be when she wears arsenal knickers ! I don't care , but I really don't like condescending muppets .

 

[Park Lane James]

What about donkey punches?

 

[Gifter]

Mumorn = mumorn , jimmy osmond = Mormon , not hard really .

Please point out where you clearly state it was never ok , as all I see is you denigrating others opinions without actually expressing one yourself.

When you stop telling people to grow up you might actually realise that the question is a good one , ie WHEN is it acceptable . The answer could be never , it could be only when she is on the rags , it may even be when she wears arsenal knickers ! I don't care , but I really don't like condescending muppets .

Bold - Then perhaps if you stop acting like one you won't receive responses in kind.

My reply that I felt their feelings on the topic were not right makes it clear that I don't feel it is right regarding the main subject, then two posts later in reply to DHSF I spell it out. As said, either you cannot fathom linear thoughts OR you used it as an excuse to have a pop because of other posts I've made (or to try to gain acceptance in your perceived pack).

Also, both Mumorn and Bush posted responses with question marks, suggesting they were also posing questions, if they get upset with me fine (though I suspect/hope Mumorn's was in jest), but you pop up acting like the thread ruler... throw in some petty digs then act like you are wronged when I snipe back.

Please put me on ignore.