The Incorrect Decisions thread

[Jurgen the German]

Chelsea should have had two penalties against QPR

Bout fudging time they had a bit of bad luck. They must have used all of it up last season.

 

[Hotshot-Tottenham]

Welbeck's dive was clearly an incorrect decision in favour of United today. Any other blatant ones anyone picked up on?

agree, but the pen was missed so there was no material affect on the outcome due to that.

 

[SUIYHA]

Bout fudging time they had a bit of bad luck. They must have used all of it up last season.

Agreed. Although I seem to remember controversial refereeing decisions in the same fixture last season...Chelsea were down to 9 men IIRC?

 

[Hotshot-Tottenham]

OP updated to reflect yesterday's games.

 

[Jurgen the German]

Agreed. Although I seem to remember controversial refereeing decisions in the same fixture last season...Chelsea were down to 9 men IIRC?

Oh yeah, but that was with AVB at the helm, their luck changed almost instantly once Di Matteo replaced him.

 

[Jurgen the German]

Crouch handballs it for Stoke's goal yesterday.

Welbeck should have been sent off for a wild lunge! At the very least, should have been a booking for the dive and a booking for the foul.

 

[SteveAWOL]

Lucky not to concede a penalty after Walker' hand of GHod moment there!

 

[markysimmo]

2 possible pens for Reading today

 

[billyiddo]

2 possible pens for Reading today

?

Gallas towards the end, but didn't see a replay but the others were fine as far as i could tell.


listening to the know-it-alls in the match thread playing Defoe was an incorrect decision so maybe that should go on the list :ross:

 

[markysimmo]

?

Gallas towards the end, but didn't see a replay but the others were fine as far as i could tell.


listening to the know-it-alls in the match thread playing Defoe was an incorrect decision so maybe that should go on the list :ross:

Handball in 1st half and Gallas clumsy tackle in stoppage time

 

[billyiddo]

there was a push on the defender before the handball, no ?

 

[Spur of the moment]

there was a push on the defender before the handball, no ?

Maybe, but tv replay suggested it wasn't much. Let's be honest, Walker got lucky.

 

[Jurgen the German]

?

Gallas towards the end, but didn't see a replay but the others were fine as far as i could tell.


listening to the know-it-alls in the match thread playing Defoe was an incorrect decision so maybe that should go on the list :ross:

Guilty

 

[Richie]

there was a push on the defender before the handball, no ?

If it was there, it was marginal. A penalty was probably the right decision.

Didn't see a replay of the Gallas pen but looked a stonewall pen to me at real time. Wouldn't have changed anything though, whistle would have blown as soon as the game was restarted

 

[Jordinho]

I see Reading fans think Howard Webb is a Spurs fan.

 

[Jurgen the German]

Walker should have conceded a pen.

Gallas clearly got the ball so that's 1 out of 2 for Webb.

 

[Spur of the moment]

I see Reading fans think Howard Webb is a Spurs fan.

Maybe it was payback time for us after all the brick decisions we've suffered from his whistle in the past.

Or maybe he always favours the bigger club.

 

[thfcsteff]

Did not look marginal at all to me. Shove in the small of the back. If he doesn't get shoved there, he isn't flying through the air in that direction. I was frankly alarmed to see Webb give the CORRECT decision!

 

[ringo]

Great thread. Be interesting to see how the swings and roundabouts, evens itself up over the season theory pans out. Could be a good sports piece in this when it is finished.

 

[Hotshot-Tottenham]

Great thread. Be interesting to see how the swings and roundabouts, evens itself up over the season theory pans out. Could be a good sports piece in this when it is finished.

:mrgreen: