|
|
-
Spurs Reserves 2-1 Aston Villa Reserves Line up/formation (ages in brackets):-----------------------------Alnwick (22)-------------------------- Smith (17)-----Butcher (18)-----Rocha (30)-----Gilberto (32) Mtandari (19)--Livermore (19)--Kasim (17)--Maghoma (21) ------------------Mason (17)-----Oyenuga (16*)--------------- Subs: Ranieri (17), Cox (18), Caulker (17), Byrne (16), Nicholson (16) Scorers: Mason (pen), Maghoma (pen) *Once again, this is a guess, since I cannot find a date of birth for him, please correct me if you happen to know.The GameWith
a number of players now out on loan, or on various youth and full
international duties, tonight’s side was largely staffed by academy
players, most of whom were involved in in the U18 game on Saturday.
With a shortage of wide midfielders and forwards, Jacques Maghoma and
Takura Mtandari were asked to occupy either flank, and U16 player Kudus
Oyenuga started up front alongside Ryan Mason. Yaser Kasim joined
captain Jake Livermore in central midfield and Calum Butcher partnered
Ricardo Rocha in central defence.
Villa are a quality side at
this level (a victory here would have seen them clinch the Reserve
League South title), and boast a player who is almost certainly a
future star in Nathan Delfouneso. In spite of this, Spurs started the
stronger, and had the better of the opening exchanges. The quality on
the ball of Mason and Kasim meant plenty of penetration centrally. As
the half wore on, Delfouneso started to cause problems on the counter
with his pace and skill, and Villa began to demonstrate their quality
before taking a deserved lead. Rocha, in particular, was looking very
uncomfortable, but Spurs struck back quickly after a clever turn and
shot by Mason deflected to Mtandari, who was brought down inside the
area. Mason converted the penalty with an unstoppable strike into the
top left corner.
At half time, Steven Caulker replaced Rocha,
who appeared to have picked up a slight knock. The second half was a
scrappy, end-to-end affair, with neither team managing any sustained
pressure. Villa still looked a threat on the counter, and Spurs looking
dangerous down the right. It was from the left though, that the winning
goal came, when Maghoma’s back heel put Gilberto into the box and he
was brought down. Maghoma stepped up, and missed the penalty with a
poor effort, but the referee ordered a retake due to encroachment, and
this time Maghoma sent the keeper the wrong way to clinch a good Spurs
victory over strong opposition.
All that was left was for coach
Clive Allen to do his regular pantomime routine and get sent to the
stands, this time for kicking over Villa’s water cooler in frustration
at a particularly inept piece of refereeing.
The Players
Starting
at the back, where things were generally quite shaky throughout,
Alnwick was once again a liability. His kicking is bad, and his
handling of crosses atrocious - electing to punch when he does decide
to come out, and usually missing or misdirecting it badly. He made a
few decent shot stopping saves, but nothing you wouldn’t expect any
keeper worthy of the name to make.
Caulker made the difference
defensively when he came on. He won headers, cleared decisively (aside
from one mishit), matched both Villa’s forwards and their wingers, when
pulled to wide areas, for pace. Butcher, who had struggled somewhat
with Delfouneso in the first half, also looked more comfortable
alongside him.
Livermore, ultimately had a good game, despite a
somewhat sluggish first half. I still think he lacks quality in some
key areas, but he made some excellent last ditch tackles in the second
half that got his defenders out of trouble.
Two players that I
have high hopes for from the academy, Mason and Kasim, put in positive
performances. Both showed real quality on the ball at times, often in
tandem - early in the first half Kasim, on the edge of the area,
somehow managed to find a pass to put Mason through that I don’t think
anyone else in the stadium could see, or probably execute (this was
incorrectly credited as Livermore’s pass on the official site).
Kasim
is a player who always tries to think several passes ahead, looks for
the forward ball first, is on the move as soon as he has released a
pass, looking for the return. He does try to complicate things on
occasion with the ball at his feet, and tonight there were a couple of
instances where he did so in dangerous areas. I think he will learn
though, as he gets used to playing at this level, and adjusts to the
reduced time players get on the ball.
Mason still has things to
learn in terms of seeking to be involved more, and taking up the right
positions as the link between midfield and attack, something I think
Clive Allen, to his credit, was trying to get across to him. Most
encouragingly though, despite his slender physique, he doesn’t seem to
be struggling with the physical side of the game at this level. He is
quickly developing the knack of positioning his body to either protect
the ball or draw fouls, rather than rely on physical strength, which
will be an important asset if he is to thrive at this level and beyond.
The Ratings
Alnwick - 44% - Poor distribution and comical attempts to deal with aerial balls. Smith - 66% - More conservative going forward than usual due to the threat in his channel from Delfouneso. Butcher - 63% - Had a few problems in the first half, but got better. Rocha
- 48% - Looked unsteady in virtually everything he did, and falling
flat on his backside unchallenged at one point summed up his evening. Gilberto - 64% - Decent enough, and actually managed to get forward effectively a couple of times. Mtandari - 67% - Stuck to his task and did well to win the first penalty Livermore - 78% - Limited offensively and technically, but worked hard defensively. Kasim - 73% - Quality and vision on the ball going forward, though could have done more defensively. Maghoma - 70% - Committed and hardworking, even when asked to play up front in the second half. Mason - 77% - Showed his technical quality when he was able to find the space to operate in. Oyenuga - 62% - Decent, hard working performance, but his opportunities were limited.
Caulker - 74% - A steady, calming influence in an otherwise quite nervy defence. Byrne - 61% - Replaced Oyenuga and put in a disciplined shift at right midfield.
|
-
Spurs Reserves 0-3 Fulham Reserves
Line up/formation (ages in brackets):---------------------------------Alnwick (22)---------------------------- Gunter (19)-------Caulker (17)--------Rocha (30)-------Bale(19) Dos Santos (19)--Livermore (19)--O’Hara (22)--Townsend (17) -------------------Campbell (21)--------Taarabt (19)------------------ Subs: L. Butcher (20), Berchiche (19), Rose (18), Mason (17), Obika (18) The MatchFor
probably the first time since the first game following Harry Redknapp
replacing Juande Ramos, the reserve side was heavily staffed with first
teamers. Although, in terms of age and Premier League appearances, it
should probably be noted that this wasn't quite as experienced a team
it may have appeared to be at first glance. Spurs lined up with a flat
4-4-2. Giovani Dos Santos and FA Youth Cup hero Andros Townsend took
the wide midfield positions, with Adel Taarabt up front alongside
Manchester United’s Fraizer Campbell. Jake Livermore continued his
rehabilitation from injury in central midfield, next to captain Jamie
O’Hara. The other standout player from the FAYC game against Arsenal,
Steven Caulker, started alongside Ricardo Rocha in defence. From
the early stages, it was apparent that Spurs weren’t going to dominate
the game in the way that the nominally strong line up may have
suggested they would. Fulham are no slouches at this level, and were
organised, motivated, and had the game’s best player in Giles Barnes,
who scored an excellent free kick to double the lead taken when Chris
Gunter’s poor back pass found Alnwick typically slow to react,
resulting in the concession of a penalty, duly converted. Throughout,
Spurs struggled to put any sustained pressure on the Fulham defence.
There was little penetration on either flank, aside from some decent
work by Townsend in the first half, and Taarabt’s tendency to
overcomplicate, and Manchester United’s Fraizer Campbell’s appalling
inability to control a ball, limited opportunities to progress through
the middle. Fulham added a third in injury time to round things off. All in all, a dire performance collectively, and in most individual cases as well. The PlayersDefensively,
only Caulker emerged with any credit. He was, as usual, dominant in the
air on straight balls from deep, and had few problems generally, given
his lack of experience at this level. At times, understandably, you can
see that he's still learning the game, particualrly in terms of where
he needs to be positionally at any given time. Alnwick
provided further evidence of why he’s miles away from being Premier
League standard - slow to react, poor kicking, suspect handling, and so
on - and both Bale and Gunter were very poor at full back. Gunter’s
poor passing cost two goals, and Bale looked lost going forward, and
unable to execute the few bright ideas that he did have. Defensively,
he looked shaky as well, as I think he tends to at left back generally.
Rocha also struggled, despite Fulham not being particularly physically
aggressive in attack. Both Livermore and Danny Rose, who
replaced him on the hour, are coming back from long term injuries, so
can be excused some lack of sharpness. Rose, for his part, at least
showed some desire to win the ball centrally. O’Hara, alongside them,
was Spurs’ best player, but even he managed to go from the sublime to
the ridiculous in his distribution. Unlike some of his first team
colleagues, he at least had the right attitude, and recognised this as
an opportunity to impress the watching first team coaching staff. Dos
Santos looked lost, for the most part, though did manage a couple of
mazy, head-down runs. I’m still not entirely sure how great the level
of talent he has is. He certainly doesn’t seem particularly aware of
his team mates, and falls behind even someone relatively inexperienced
like Townsend, in that regard, I would say. Townsend himself did well
for periods of the game, particularly first half. Those who have seen
more of him than last Thursday’s man of the match performance, will
have recognised this as being more in line with a typical performance
of his though - occasional bright spots, interspersed with long periods
of being peripheral. Some of this is down to the type of player he is,
being an old school winger who requires decent service, but I think he
also has to learn that he needs to seek and demand the ball more as
well, either by communicating with his team mates, or by the runs and
positions he takes. Taarabt had another of those games to
forget, and his performance was very much in line with his performances
at this level all season. Once again trying too hard, overcomplicating
in situations that clearly don’t require it, and slowing play down
generally. As usual though, he still managed a few moments of quality
amongst the madness, including one excellent through ball over the top
of the last man. Obika and Mason both came off the bench and did
no harm to their claims for further chances at this level. Obika
struggled for service, with such a lack of ideas from midfield behind
him, but did show a few signs of his ever improving confidence with the
ball at his feet, be that picking a pull back pass to the edge of the
area from out wide, or using a bit of skill to create space for a shot
inside the box. Mason’s passing immediately caught the eye when he
entered proceedings to play wide right in midfield. Two or three
excellent switches of play to the left flank, and displaying obvious
comfort with the ball at his feet. Finally, a few words on
Manchester United’s Fraizer Campbell. A player, let’s not forget,
denying the likes of Mason and Obika the chance to gain more experience
at this, and higher, levels. Actually no, I’m not going to put any more
effort into describing his performance, than he himself put into it. I
guess we can at least take comfort from the evidence before us that our
own academy is now managing to produce players that are technically
light years ahead of at least one example from United’s much vaunted
set up. The RatingsAlnwick - 53% - Makes even routine saves look like hard work. Gunter - 41% - Lapses in concentration, which were unfortunately punished. Caulker - 67% - Looked pretty comfortable at this level. Rocha - 51% - Struggled with his direct opponents both aerially and on the deck. Bale - 44% - Poor passing and poor defensively. Dos Santos - 57% - Couple of decent runs, but mainly a peripheral figure. Livermore - 58% - Looked off the pace for the most part, understandably. O’Hara - 72% - Hit and miss distribution, but application and attitude was right. Townsend - 64% - Decent first half, but faded and needs to seek the ball more. Taarabt - 54% - Same old story, overcomplicating and slowing play down. Campbell - 34% - Awful player, playing awfully, with virtually zero commitment Obika - 62% - Virtually no service, but did some decent things with what scraps he got. Rose - 60% - Passing was sloppy, but added some bite centrally. Mason - 65% - His accurate passing and awareness made him stand out like a sore thumb in this company.
|
-
Coventry U18s 1-2 Spurs U18s
Line up/formation
--------------------Jansson--------------------
Smith------Butcher------Caulker-----Byrne
Mpuku----Livermore-----Cox----Townsend
-------------Mason------Oyenuga-------------
Substitutions: Bostock for Mason (40 mins), Kasim for Livermore (H-T), Nicholson for Oyenuga (80mins)
Scorers: Butcher, Smith
The Game
Spurs
lined up with a somewhat unfamiliar side, with several key players
either seemingly rested ahead of the FAYC game against Arsenal, or not involved due to appearances in the UEFA Cup for the
first team (Dean Parrett and Jonathan Obika, although Obika was with
the group in Coventry doing some light training). In Obika’s absence,
U-16 player Kudus Oyenuga started up front with Ryan Mason. In central
midfield, Sam Cox was joined by Jake Livermore (as one of the three
permitted overage U19 players, I believe), given some playing time
after recovering from a long term injury.
The unfamiliarity
contributed to a sluggish start by Spurs, and Coventry had several
chances in the opening minutes, mostly from set pieces, one of which
they took. With Livermore and Cox unable to assert themselves
centrally, it was hard to see how Spurs could get a foothold in the
match. Fortunately, that opportunity came from a set piece - the
excellent Calum Butcher (captaining the side) heading in Andros
Townsend’s corner at the near post. Shortly before half time, John
Bostock replaced the injured Mason in a straight swap
At half
time, Alex Inglethorpe made some key changes to both personnel and
system. Livermore was replaced by Yaser Kasim in a central midfield
three alongside Bostock and Cox, and Townsend and Paul-Jose Mpuku were
pushed forward on the flanks to make a 4-3-3, with Oyenuga at point.
Almost immediately, Spurs looked more comfortable. In Kasim, there was
finally a player to both bring the ball forward and dictate play from
central midfield, and with the added security of the three in the
middle, Adam Smith at right back was able to get forward. These two key
elements were in full effect for the winning goal - Kasim bringing the
ball forward and slotting an excellent through ball in behind
Coventry's left back for Smith to pick up, cut back onto his left, and
put a cross-shot inside the far post, courtesy of a deflection.
The Players
In
defence, Calum Butcher was particularly impressive. With his partner
Caulker struggling at times, it was often left to Butcher to retrieve
the situation with a last ditch tackle or interception, which is one of
the strongest features of his game. It was also encouraging to hear him
being a vocal captain, not afraid, for example, to send some stern
words in Bostock’s direction after some sloppy play.
In goal,
Oscar Jansson looked quite shaky, particularly on crosses, and the
defence in general looked vulnerable in that regard. Nathan Byrne was
quietly impressive at left back - quite solid in his defensive
positioning and in one-on-one situations, as Coventry looked to attack
mainly down his flank.
The player who probably most changed the
game though, was Kasim. As I’ve said before, a very tactically and
technically impressive player, who with Cox given the main defensive
responsibilities, was able to showcase more of the attacking side of
his game on this occasion. Comfortable with the ball at his feet, aware
of movement and options around him and usually choosing the right one.
It probably says it all that Kasim tends to be the first player the
coaches look to when passing instructions and tactical changes to the
team.
Further forward, it wasn’t really a good day for the
attackers. Townsend and Mpuku didn’t get much joy out of a pretty
resolute Coventry side, and Oyenuga, despite physically being the equal
of the older players he is playing with and against, showed that he is
still learning the game, particularly in terms of the movement and
decision making required when playing as the most advanced forward.
Bostock also struggled to get into the game, and his involvement was
mainly limited to a few long range shots.
Finally, it’s worth
mentioning Mason. Until Kasim
came on, Mason looked the most likely to create something, playing in
the hole behind Oyenuga. Much like Kasim, technically sound, and with
what appears to be a good footballing brain, I’m pretty sure he’s the
kind of player that Spurs fans will appreciate as they (hopefully) get
to see more of over the coming years.
|
-
Charlton 0-3 Tottenham
--------------------------Jansson (18)------------------------
Smith (17)----Butcher (17)------Caulker (17)----Cox (18)
Mpuku (16)---Kasim (17)---Parrett (17)---Townsend (17)
---------------------------Bostock (17)------------------------
---------------------------Obika (18)--------------------------
Subs: Butler
(16), Oyenuga (15/16*), Ekim (17), Byrne (16), Nicholson (16)
* It’s one or the other, since he’s in the U16 group, i.e. a
year below the academy first years, but since his date of birth doesn’t appear
to be listed anywhere, I’m not sure whether he’s hit 16 yet.
The Game
Spurs lined up with Jonathan Obika up front on his own, with
Bostock playing ahead of a four man midfield to provide support to him. Yaser Kasim
anchored midfield along side Dean Parrett, who captained the side. Andros
Townsend and Paul-Jose Mpuku took up the wide midfield spots, and both held
their starting positions as Spurs looked to expand the area of play to aid a quick
tempo, possession game. Most attacks were focused down the left flank, with Townsend
seeing a lot of the ball throughout.
In the opening stages, it looked like Charlton may be
overwhelmed, much as Sheffield United had been in the previous round, but to
their credit, by the midway point of the first half they had steadied
themselves, reorganised, and were looking difficult to break down. Despite
Spurs dominating possession, it looked like something special would be needed
to break their resilience, and Bostock duly provided it with a stunning long
range drive that flew into the top right corner of the goal, drawing applause
from virtually everyone in attendance.
Bostock’s second was less spectacular, but still of
impressive quality. His shot from the edge of the area nestling in the bottom corner pretty much ended
the tie as a contest, and the game played out with Spurs looking an increasing
threat on the counter when Charlton did manage to construct an attack. Obika
sealed the victory with the third goal from Parrett’s through pass and the game
played out with Kasim looking to exploit the pace of Townsend and Mpuku (then Kudus
Oyengua who replaced him) on the break with, early balls into the channels.
Once again, I have to praise Alex Inglethorpe. For all the
talent that this group of players may have individually, it’s no accident for
them collectively to play the way they do. They are very well organised, with
each player clearly well drilled in what is expected of him both with and
without the ball. Inglethorpe’s team play football precisely how, I’m sure,
every Spurs fan would hope to see a side play. There are no long, hopeful balls
from back to front – this side play with the ball on the ground, alternating
between quick, pass and move, football to penetrate, and slower possession play
to grind the opposition down – the team
is set up to be balanced, to attack and to dominate. Inglethorpe's team arguably play a better brand of football than any first team manager at Spurs has achieved since Glenn Hoddle's stint (and unlike the karmic one, it's proving successful), and you can't help but wonder what he'd achieve in a higher position.
The Players
Bostock, understandably, will grab the headlines. Both goals
were well taken, the first a superb strike. Generally though, it was a fairly
quiet performance from him. It’s quite hard to judge his potential in this context, because it’s quite
clear that he’s beyond this level of football now – the combination of his
physical and technical qualities mean it’s virtually impossible for opponents
to contain him, and consequently they don’t provide a very useful barometer for
his development. I do think he needs to impose himself more on games, but
having said that, it’s pretty obvious that this boy is going to make it,
somewhere and somehow, barring something extremely unfortunate.
Almost equally impressive was Kasim. Technically, I’d say he’s
as good as any other player in the side – first touch passing off either foot,
long range passing off either foot, ability on the ball (including one
outrageous piece of showboating from a short corner near the end) – and is
always calm and aware when he receives the ball. His head is invariably up,
assessing what is around him, which always impresses me in a young player, and he tends to see things very early. He
also gets stuck in and works hard to win the ball back, which is encouraging as
the defensive side of his game is, along with maybe his mobility, one of the
few things that would concern me about him.
On the whole though, I continue to be very impressed with
him. He improved as the game went on, and really came into his own as Charlton
made one final push in the closing period, pinging some exquisite long range angled
through balls to the flanks, and one beautifully weighted pass inside the left back to put Oyenuga one
on one with the keeper.
Alongside him, in central midfield, Parrett had a strong
first half, and looked comfortable throughout in a central role. He was
probably the liveliest Spurs player in the first half, breaking forward with the
ball at his feet on several occasions. As the game went on, with Kasim
collecting the ball in deep areas, and Bostock tending to dominate proceedings the final third, Parrett saw less of the ball, but still, it was a good, disciplined
performance from the captain, culminating in a cute pass to set up Obika for
the third goal.
On the left flank, Townsend reminds me of Aaron Lennon – you’re
not always sure what you’re going to get in terms of the quality of his end
product, yet he is a constant threat to the opposition. Townsend is quick, skilful and direct,
and if he can refine his game, and avoid overcomplicating, he seems pretty well equiped
to progress to the next level.
The youngest player in the starting eleven, Mpuku, had a
relatively quiet game on the right of midfield. When he did see the ball
though, he did look good – strong, quick and technically good (like a lot of
players in this group to be honest, which is one of the things that makes them
exciting). Very early days for him, but I would say he has something about him,
even if it’s a bit too soon to say precisely what.
Of the rest, it almost goes without saying that Adam Smith was
impressive at right back. Going forward, he’s excellent, most notably in the
variation he shows in his attacking play. He can run with the ball on the
outside or come inside and take it into central areas; will look to get to the
byline and cross, but is equally likely to mix it up, pass and move and push up into the box. Defensively, he wasn’t really troubled, and that’s the side
of his game I’m eager to see more of, because if it is anything like the
attacking side, he’s a real prospect.
Jansson in goal looked good – always tries to catch, and is
quick off his line. The problem for him is that playing in a team as good as
this one, he doesn’t have a great deal to do. It will be interesting to see
where they see him fitting in over the next twelve months, given that he’s
already been involved with the first team.
The only real negative from the night was that the centre
back pair, Butcher and Caulker, looked a
little nervy at times, much more so than in the previous round, and Charlton
nearly capitalised on a couple of occasions. Other than that, it was all very encouraging, and I'd say this team have a good chance of going far in this competition.
The Ratings
Jansson – 75% - Assured and proactive when called upon.
Smith – 78% - Always lively going forward, and had few
troubles defensively.
Butcher – 63% - Suffered a few lapses, but was generally able to recover the situation.
Caulker – 60% - Struggled with the ball at his feet at times.
Cox – 64% - Hard working, but playing on the left restricts
his attacking involvement to some extent.
Mpuku – 73% - A marginal figure, but looked good when he was
involved.
Kasim – 81% - Class and composure on the ball and a decent defensive shift.
Parrett – 77% - Very good first half, driving forward from
central midfield.
Townsend – 80% Always looked a threat, even if he
over complicated things at times.
Bostock – 84% - Two excellent goals and opponents clearly struggle to handle him at this level.
Obika – 68% - Did OK in a role that required him to be quite
selfless for the sake of the team.
|
-
Tottenham 3-0 Sheffield
United
Line up/formation (ages in brackets)
------------------------Jansson
(17)-------------------------
--Smith (17)---Butcher (17)---Caulker (16)---Cox (18)--
Parrett (17)--Bostock (16)--Kasim (17)--Townsend (17)
---------------Mason (17)---------Obika (18)--------------
Subs: Butler
(16), Ekim (17), Mpuku (16), Byrne (16), Oyenuga (15)
Scorers: Obika x3
The Game
Spurs lined up in a standard 4-4-2 formation, with Jonathan
Obika as main striker and Ryan Mason dropping deeper. In midfield, Yaser Kasim was
the holding player, and Dean Parrett played wide right to accommodate John
Bostock in the middle. Steven Caulker was captain until he was withdrawn with a thigh injury, and Calum Butcher took over the responsibility.
From the very first minute, it was pretty clear that Spurs
were the vastly superior side. The only surprise was that it took them so long
to kill the game off having taken the lead. Sheffield United managed few
chances, and were mostly mere spectators, like the rest of us, to Spurs’
impressive, cultured display. Most of the attacking threat for Spurs came from
the right flank, particularly in the first half, where the excellent Adam Smith
was causing United all sorts of problems on the overlap. Attacking play on the
opposite flank was less impressive, with Townsend struggling to get involved,
and Sam Cox not really contributing much offensively. In the centre, for all
Bostock’s impressive work, it was Kasim and Mason coming deep who provided the
more telling creative passes. Ultimately, Spurs’ superiority paid off - five
times Obika found himself through on goal, and three times he finished smartly,
wrapping up a hat trick and the victory.
Another impressive result for Alex Inglethorpe’s
side, and the coach must take some credit for the style and organisation he
manages to achieve with these players. His team play a slick, short passing game, with the ball on
the ground and a reliance on good combination play to open teams up. Much like
reserve boss Clive Allen, Inglethorpe doesn’t seem to be a particularly vocal
coach on the sidelines, but unlike Allen, he has his side playing a very well
structured and organised system in which players know their roles and responsibilities, and is
clear in his instructions to the players when he does intervene.
Inglethorpe first impressed me whilst he was managing Exeter City,
and I was delighted (and quite surprised) when he joined Spurs to manage the
youth team. He continues to impress me, and I suspect he is on the verge of
delivering the best crop of academy players in recent memory to the reserves.
As such, he should be rewarded, in my opinion, by graduating with his players and
succeeding Clive Allen as reserve manager, thus allowing him to continue his
role in the development of this group of players.
The Players
The two strikers, fresh from their first team debuts, will
have been of interest to many. Obika obviously bagged a hat trick, but also
missed another two clear chances. As I’ve said before, though strong and quick,
he looks awkward at times, and his all round game probably needs major
improvement before he can be considered a serious prospect. Having said that,
his progression over the past six months seems to me to have been massive, and if he can
continue to develop at that kind of rate, he may have a chance.
Mason looks a bright, intelligent player. His technique is
pretty good, he’s quick with the ball at
his feet, and has good vision and awareness. On this occasion he didn’t really
provide a threat on goal, save one well worked shot from distance, due to his
deeper role, but some of his approach work was impressive. He does need to bulk
up considerably though – his thighs are probably the same size as Bostock’s
biceps - before he can make an impact at a higher level.
The two most hyped players in this group are Bostock and
Parrett. In Parrett’s case, it was a game to forget. He struggled to get
involved playing wide right, and his pass selection and general decision making
was clearly below the level of some of his team mates’. I have to say, I
couldn’t really see any particular aspect of his game that would explain why he
is so highly rated. His technique was decent enough, but I wouldn’t say it
stands above the general level of the team, and neither his passing or work on the ball was impressive on this occasion.
Bostock put in a positive performance. His technique,
ability and confidence on the ball are very impressive, although there is a
danger of him over complicating at times. As encouraging as his game was, it has to
be said that very little of his play lead to much by way of end
product. He completely dominates opponents physically at this level, and to
some extent that makes him harder to judge as a player, because once he steps
up to the first team, that advantage will largely disappear. Still, he’s quite
clearly a big prospect (in both senses), and barring some ‘off the rails’ deviance from his
current path, will almost certainly become a Premier League level player in the
future.
Both midfield ‘wonderkids’ were upstaged by Kasim, whose performance was hugely impressive. His passing was excellent, off either
foot, short and long. On a couple of occasions, he took the ball smartly on to his left foot
and lofted an inch perfect through ball for the forwards. Defensively, he
looked quite good also – strong in the tackle, and aware of threats around him.
I would like to see him properly tested against a stronger opposition first,
but he certainly seems the kind of cultured, dictating holding midfielder that has been
lacking in the reserve group (and arguably first team) for some time.
Spurs’ best performer on the night was another player who
has had a taste of first team football – right back Adam Smith. He’s very
impressive going forward - his runs are well timed, he has sufficient skill and
pace to get past players in the final third, and his end product is generally good. He’s
comfortable attacking his opponent on the outside, or bringing the ball inside
and breaking directly toward goal. As I’ve said before, if he can improve
defensively and become physically stronger, I can see a path to more first team
involvement for him, even though there is depth in his position at the moment.
Of the rest of the back four, central defenders Caulker and Butcher looked
an impressive partnership. They are pretty much the classic English centre back
pairing, with Caulker the strong, quick, dominant presence, and Butcher the
sweeping, anticipatory, reader of danger. Caulker, particularly is the perfect
build for his position – tall, strong but not so big that his mobility is
restricted.
In goal, Oscar Jansson had a relatively quiet game, but his
handling, when required, was immaculate, and he was very quick to take
responsibility by coming off his line, either on crossed balls/set pieces or to sweep up
through balls. It’s easy to see why he has been fast tracked to first team
duty.
Belgian summer signing from Standard Liege, Paul-Jose M'puku, also made an appearance from the bench, and looked bright - creating the third goal for Obika, and showing some decent technique on the ball.
The Ratings
Jansson – 74% - Performed all that was required of him with a degree of class.
Smith – 86% - Excellent going forward, which had his
opponents resorting to dubious methods to try and stop him.
Butcher – 71% - A few impressive tackles and interventions.
Caulker – 73% - Dominant in the air and physically strong.
Cox – 62% - Struggled to provide any attacking contribution.
Parret – 54% - When he did see the ball, his play and decision making were not great.
Bostock – 76% - Showed plenty of skill and dominance of opponents without actually creating much.
Kasim – 82% - Superb passing at times and a decent defensive
shift as well.
Townsend – 63% - Quick and direct, but wasn’t involved
enough.
Mason – 72% - Some smart play, but really needed to be
involved further forward.
Obika – 84% - Always looked a threat when on the last man
and could, perhaps should, have scored more.
|
-
Spurs Reserves 0-2 Stoke Reserves
Line up/formation (ages in brackets)
-------------------------Alnwick (21)-------------------------
Mtandari (19)---Dervite (20)--Rocha (30)---Gilberto (32)
-------------------------McKenna (22)------------------------
-------------Ghaly (26)---------------Boateng (21)----------
Fraser-Allen (18)-------------------------------Daniels (22)
-------------------------Taarabt
(19)-------------------------
Subs: Butcher (20), Berchiche (18), Maghoma (21), Hutton
(18), Hutchins (19)
The Game
It was a bitterly cold evening, and a performance from the
Spurs side that was similarly lacking in appeal. Once again, Clive Allen had an
experienced squad at his disposal, and chose to configure the side much as he
did last time out - Adel Taarabt, Charlie Daniels and Kyle Fraser-Allen
interchanging as a front three, Hossam Ghaly and Kevin-Prince Boateng behind them in midfield either side of a holding player, in this case Kieran McKenna. Dorian Dervite captained as
usual, although it was former Northern Ireland U-21 captain McKenna who was
most vocal.
Stoke’s clear desire, much like their first team, to
frustrate through good organisation and go direct in possession, along with
Spurs’ disjointed attacking endeavours, made for a poor game, which was not aided by a
poor refereeing performance. Clive Allen was eventually sent from the bench by
the referee as his frustration at several poor decisions grew, but Allen
himself must take some blame for his side’s performance in attempting to match
Stoke at their own physical game, rather than using his own side’s superior passing ability to
strike an advantage.
Although he did seek to switch emphasis at half time –
Dervite and Gilberto were removed, the former presumably because of injury and
the latter presumably because he was appalling, with Mtandari switching to
centreback and Danny Hutchins coming in at right back, Daniels reverting to
left back and Jacques Maghoma on to sit alongside McKenna in midfield - by that point Stoke had already gained a goal
advantage following some poor defending at the far post by Mtandari from a
crossed ball. As Stoke galvanised their soak-up-pressure/break-directly
approach, Spurs could not achieve much meaningful penetration, despite having shifted to a
more flank based attacking style, with both fullbacks Hutchins and Berchiche
(who replaced McKenna near the hour mark) providing far better overlapping options than either of
their first half counterparts.
Once a poor pass in his own defensive third from Boateng, followed
by a sluggish reaction from Mtandari, had gifted Stoke their second, it was all over.
The only kind of threat posed by Spurs for the remainder, as heads dropped, was set
pieces, from which delivery had been poor all evening.
The Players
Last time out, Boateng had been the best Spurs player on
show, and the early signs were that it would be a similar story this time. In the
first half, he again posed some physical problems for the opposition defence
and made several cute passes out wide in advanced areas to release the front three. However, his influence waned as the second half progressed,
at times trying to over complicate things, but more worryingly getting
increasingly involved in fracas with Stoke players. There we a couple of off
the ball incidents, and on several occasions he left his foot in or followed
through on challenges. Thankfully, the referee was incompetent enough to miss
most of them, or Boateng would surely have seen a red, rather than the single yellow,
card. At times it’s hard to tell with Boateng whether he really is that close
to the edge of losing it, or whether it’s all about gamesmanship and calculated
attempts to wind opponents up, disrupt their concentration and bait them into being carded. Either way, given the fine line he currently walks in terms of a
future at the club, he’d probably be advised to alter his approach: a red card, even at this level,
would almost certainly bring his career at the club to an end, one suspects.
Another player not unfamiliar with controversy, Ghaly, was
one of the few positives to be taken from the evening. Again, a disciplined performance in a central role, but this time he displayed more of
the creativity that had marked his return a couple of games ago. He linked well
with his team mates in the final third, and most of his passing, including the more
ambitious attempts, came off. Once again, I would say that there is no reason
why Ghaly shouldn’t be in consideration for the first team on the merits of his ability
alone, but whether that is actually an option, given the previous policy of
excluding him, remains a doubt.
Another plus point would be Danny Hutchins, who again showed
promise, this time when brought into the fray as right back at half time. Indeed, in his
first action of the game, he managed to contribute more in attacking terms than
Mtandari had for the entire first half - advancing and cutting inside from the
flank to thread a smart through ball into the channel. He continued to
provide a good overlapping outlet throughout the game, and also defended reasonably well. He appears comfortable with the
ball at either foot, plays with his head up and shows a good understanding of the
game for a 19 year old. I think his future probably lies in central midfield,
rather than full back, but at this point it is important that he’s playing, and
his versatility will aid in that.
The negative points have to begin with Gilberto, who is fast
proving himself incapable at reserve level, never mind Premier League level.
It bewilders me that, unless he has declined rapidly over the past year or so as
age catches up with him, he has been anywhere near any national team in recent times, never
mind one as prestigious as Brazil’s. In fact, he’s probably one of the least technically
accomplished Brazilians I can remember coming across (and by that I mean
Brazilians per se, not just Brazilian footballers). On this occasion, he was
poor on the ball, and appeared to have no idea where and when he should be
going forward and providing support. He shouldn’t be anywhere near the first
team, despite our current lack of quality in that position. It’s a shame
because he seems like a nice enough guy, who has boldly uprooted to a new
country for one last challenge, and I particularly like the fact that he always
looks like he is struggling with constipation in photographs, but unfortunately
he also plays football as if troubled by a similar problem.
No reserve report these days would be complete without some
mention of the Taarabt conundrum. On this occasion, he was slightly better than
he has been for a while, for the most part solely because some of the tricks
and manoeuvres he attempted actually came off (though still with virtually nothing by
way of final product). His tendency to completely destroy any attack by hanging
onto the ball regardless of the circumstances, location on the pitch or actions
of his team mates around him was still evident though. Despite having a decent
arsenal of tricks in his locker, he quickly becomes entirely predictable for
opponents, and most these days are dealing with him comfortably. He has quite clearly gone backwards in terms of knowing when to release the ball, to the point where it now only happens when he's explored every available blind alley and has no remaining option. Having said
all that, he’s probably not being helped by having a coach who clearly doesn’t
know how, or indeed where, to use him.
Another player who will probably be of interest given recent
events at first team level is goalkeeper Ben Alnwick, returning from loan to start here.
Whilst it’s worth noting that he did all the 'keeping basics well enough,
it also has to be said that he’s not much of a commanding presence, and his
distribution was routinely awful – virtually all of his kicking failed to get anywhere
near its intended target, and most of the time he was choosing the wrong target
anyway. I doubt he will provide an answer at first team level, although in
fairness, he doesn’t look any less likely to do so than Cesar Sanchez.
The final player worthy of a mention is McKenna, particularly since the
official channels have given him a glowing report for his performance. He certainly
put in a good shift, but although he reads the game quite well, he lacks a
certain degree of quality on arriving into those defensive situations that he is trying to resolve, and that, I suspect, is
ultimately why he is probably heading for no more than a departure to a lower
league club. His defensive awareness is also cancelled out somewhat by his lack of
understanding of options ahead of him, and most of his passing was unnecessarily
negative, at a time when the team desperately needed to exert its authority in that regard over their opponents.
The Ratings
Alnwick – 64% - His handling was good, but he isn't really a great presence and his distribution is woeful.
Mtandari – 41% - Awful performance in both positions. At
fault for both goals and offered nothing in attack from right back.
Dervite – 55% - Had few problems due to Stoke’s direct style
and the fact that dealing with aerial balls/physical strikers is the strongest part
of his game.
Rocha – 67% - Similarly, coped manfully with Stoke’s gameplan,
despite not having the advantage of Dervite’s physical characteristics.
Gilberto – 44% - Poor on the ball, poor going forward. Looks
like he doesn’t know what he, or his team mates are doing most of the time.
Ghaly – 74% - The closest Spurs had to someone dictating the
game, most of his passing and decision making was good, particularly in the final third.
McKenna – 72% - Generally a good, disciplined game, though his
passing is very negative and unimaginative.
Boateng – 61% - Started well, then got progressively worse,
and was getting closer and closer to being sent off.
Fraser-Allen – 63% - Posed zero threat out wide, but once
again put in a spirited performance when alone up front.
Daniels – 54% - His final delivery from wide areas was poor
tonight, and that is really the only thing he potentially brings to the team.
Taarabt – 59% - Slight improvement on previous games, but he
is still doing as much harm as good in terms of the team’s attacking play
|
-
Spurs Reserves 2-0 West Ham Reserves
Line up/formation (ages in brackets):
---------------------Sanchez (37)---------------------
Stalteri (31)--Dervite (20)--Rocha (30)--Gilberto (32)
--------Ghaly (26)--Maghoma (21)--Boateng (21)----
Daniels (22)---------------------------------Taarabt (19)
--------------------Fraser-Allen (18)-------------------
Subs: Butcher (20), Mtandari (19), Hutchins (19),
Berchiche (18), Hutton (18)
Scorers: Daniels x2
The Game
It was a good turn out for a cold, rainy Monday evening. Numbers
no doubt buoyed by it being a derby with West Ham, and also by the promise of
the return of some senior Spurs players that were frozen out under the previous regime.
That prospect was also enough to attract the likes of new manager Harry
Redknapp, new coach Tim Sherwood and fellow Spurs “legend” Justin Edinburgh to the game.
Spurs lined up with an incredibly experienced backline (youngest member Dervite retained the captaincy), with
Jacques Maghoma anchoring midfield and Hossam Ghaly and Kevin Prince Boateng
also central (disappointingly no place for two of this year's better reserve
performers David Hutton and Danny Hutchins). Beyond them, three nominal
attacking players, Adel Taarabt, Charlie Daniels and Kyle Fraser-Allen were
given some free licence to switch positions. This lead to a disjointed first
half, as the players struggled to come to terms with such flexibility in their roles, and the lack of a consistent focal point in attack meant the breakdown
of most offensive moves as they reached the final third. Any goal threat was limited to
speculative long range efforts (Daniels turned in a Gilberto strike but was ruled offside), set pieces and several crosses into a largely unpopulated
penalty area.
Eventually, as the half wore on, reserve coach Clive Allen settled on using Fraser-Allen as a
fixed striker, with Taarabt on the left flank and Daniels on the right. Still
not happy with that, he brought on Hutton at half time (along with Takura
Mtandari to replace the injured Rocha) and switched to 4-4-1-1, with Hutton and
Daniels on either flank, Ghaly and Maghoma central and Boateng in a roaming
role behind Fraser-Allen.
The greater balance and fixed structure paid dividends and Spurs' dominance over
a very poor West Ham side was rewarded with two goals, both from Daniels. The
first a tap in from a corner following Boateng’s header, and the second a
superb solo goal from Daniels breaking from left midfield.
The Players
The most impressive player on display on the night turned
out to be Boateng. I, like the vast majority, had completely written him off,
as a player who has failed to look the part at first team level and has
reportedly had some off the field problems alongside rumours of a poor attitude. His
attitude in this game though was excellent. He worked extremely hard to make an
impact, particularly in the second half, and I was particularly impressed with
a hitherto unseen level of intelligence in his play.
Physically, he looked like
a man against boys opposite the majority of West Ham’s back line, winning
plenty of headers and flick ons from deep balls and closing and bullying
defenders. I can’t really see where he would play should he return to first
team consideration, but on this evidence, perhaps as an option as a support forward. I’d imagine Redknapp will be pretty impressed with his application,
and of all the ‘misfits’ has probably done himself the most good from his
night’s work.
Of the other senior players hoping to force their way back
into the reckoning, Paul Stalteri was probably the most impressive. He looked
rusty and lacking sharpness, particularly defensively in the first half
(understandable since this was his first ‘competitive’ club game in months),
but as ever provided some intelligent overlapping down the right flank as the
game went on.
Gilberto, despite looking pretty bright early on, got worse
as the game went on and was a passenger for the majority of the second half.
Rocha did OK, but as ever does tend to commit himself rather early, and didn’t
appear for the second half having picked up what looked like an ankle injury.
Ghaly, very impressive last time out, was much quieter in
this game. The role he had occupied last time was taken this time by Boateng,
and as such a more disciplined game was required from him, which he managed
with minimum fuss. There were a few more misplaced passes this time around, but
in general his understanding of what is around him in both defensive and
attacking situations is still impressive, and may well surprise those who wrote
him off at senior level.
Daniels deserves a mention on account of his brace on the
night, in addition to his goal last time out. For me, he is providing further
evidence that there is little point in judging a player by their reserve
goalscoring record (see also Lee Barnard). Although his second goal was very
well taken, he is nowhere near sufficient level to make it at a club like
Spurs. Plenty of enthusiasm, but lacks mobility and any quality in his final
ball. Could certainly carve a decent career for himself at lower league level,
and that is precisely where he should be right now, for his own sake if nothing
else.
As for Taarabt…. well, one could write a very long thesis on
how and why it all went wrong for him at Spurs, but it’s quite clear that it
HAS gone wrong. In the first half, virtually everything he tried was counter to
the higher tempo, quick ball moving game that Allen wanted, and he was quite
clearly doing more harm than good with his insistence on trying to beat a
player every time he received the ball, regardless of where he was and what the
situation required.
It’s a real shame because it’s pretty easy to see the talent
he does have, and not just in the tricks and party pieces, but also in some of
his passing and awareness of team mates’ movements. Were this a one off, it
could probably be put down to over eagerness at the opportunity to impress the
new manager, but it’s been happening all season, and at the tail end of last
term aswell.
Personally, I can’t see any way back for him. Right now, he’s
not playing well enough to be anywhere near first team consideration. Unless
Redknapp or one of the other new coaches can take him under their wing, I’d say
it’s unlikely that there’s going to be any improvement – it’s clear that Allen
isn’t going to be the one to turn his fortunes around.
The Ratings
Sanchez – 59% - Had very little to do but, one poor rush
from goal aside, did it competently
Stalteri – 70% - Clearly lacking sharpness, but was a decent
attacking outlet
Dervite – 67% - Looked better than in recent games. A little
shaky in one on ones though.
Rocha – 61% - Had no major problems before being withdrawn
Gilberto – 55% - Thankfully wasn’t really tested
defensively, but failed to provide much of an attacking outlet
Maghoma – 58% - Coped physically, but some of his positional
play and wayward passing caused a few problems
Ghaly – 66% - Steady and disciplined for the most part
Boateng – 75% - Plenty of enthusiasm, as you might expect,
but also some glimpses of quality and maturity
Taarabt – 44% - Caused more problems for his team mates and
coach than he did for the opposition
Daniels – 73% - Two well taken goals, and can’t fault his
effort, but they were the only real moments of quality
Fraser-Allen – 61% - A big ask for him to play up top, but put
in a decent shift
Mtandari – 60% - West Ham didn’t ask any real questions of
him.
Hutton – 63% - Provided some much needed balance and pace on
the flanks
|
-
Spurs Reserves 2-3 Portsmouth Reserves
Line up/formation (ages in brackets):
-------------------------------Sanchez
(37)-----------------------------
Smith
(17)-------Dervite (20)--------Rocha (29)-------Hughton (19)
----------------McKenna
(22)-------Maghoma (20)-------------------
Hutton
(18)--------------------Ghaly (26)-----------------Daniels (22)
-------------------------------Taarabt
(19)-----------------------------
Subs:
Butler (16),
Berchiche (18), Mtandari (18), Olsen (18), Fraser-Allen (18)
Scorers:
Daniels, Taarabt
The Game
Second home game of the season for the reserves, and I know first
team coaches Gus Poyet and Hans Leitert were both in attendance, as I passed
them on the stairs on the way in (Hans courteously held the door open for me as
well, so brownie points for him). The much maligned Damien Comolli was also
watching, but I didn’t see Ramos.
With a couple of older players who had been absent through season long loan and injury, in Daniels and McKenna respectively, returning and three ‘senior’ players in the starting line up, Spurs suddenly
looked quite an old side for this kind of fixture. Portsmouth were the
opposition and, some fringe first teamers such as Traore, Little and
Jerome Thomas aside, looked disjointed and lacking in quality. Their team was presumably made up largely of younger players, and that disparity
in experience and quality between the two sides certainly told, as Portsmouth were rarely
in the game, despite the final score not reflecting Spurs' dominance.
Overall, this is the best I’ve seen the reserves play for
some time. They looked organised, motivated, and played some decent stuff at
times. It’s amazing what a few experienced heads can do to a side like this,
and is precisely why I keep advocating senior players not getting first team
minutes being part of this group. Someone like Adam Smith is going to benefit
immensely from having a goalkeeper of Cesar Sanchez’ experience instructing
him, for example.
Spurs lined up in what was essentially a 4-2-3-1, with
Taarabt, somewhat nonsensically, as sole striker. Maghoma and McKenna anchored midfield
(Danny Hutchins, impressive in that role so far this season, was there but not in the
eleven or named as sub), with David Hutton and Charlie Daniels on either flank,
and Hossam ‘back from the dead’ Ghaly given a relatively free role to drop into
midfield or support Taarabt. Dervite was captain.
Spurs dominated the first half entirely, though the lack of
a proper striker hampered them greatly. The first goal came from a good strike
from Daniels, teed up by Taarabt from a freekick, and the second from some good
interplay between Ghaly and Taarabt, resulting in a speculative shot (one of many) from
Taarabt.
Daniels managed to undo his contribution of the opening goal by failing to track
his man to allow Portsmouth to equalise, and in
the second half, Portsmouth
managed to nick the two goals that gave them the win through some poor
defending, where first Sanchez and then Rocha were exposed as the only line of
defence. This was despite the visitors failing to look a genuine threat
throughout.
The Players
There’s only one place to start, and that is with the player
I, and I’m sure everyone else, assumed would never be seen in a Spurs shirt
ever again – Hossam Ghaly. To put it succinctly, Ghaly was a class above
everyone else on the pitch. His work rate was superb. In the first half, he
was everywhere, making himself an option for the pass virtually every time a Spurs player had the
ball, threw himself into tackles and made intelligent contributions defensively,
and looked by far the player most likely to create chances via an incisive
through ball or interplay in advanced areas. For the closing stages of the
first half, and the whole of the second, Clive Allen instructed him to play up
alongside Taarabt, and he continued to make a good contribution from that
position – linking well with Taarabt, for the most part, and playing some
decent angled through balls to the right to put in Hutton and Smith on several
occasions.
This of course is a player coming back from injury, who hasn’t
played first team football for months, and playing in the stiffs for a club who
has shunned him since a moment of petulance brought on by idiotic elements in
the crowd. For him to come out and show the effort and enthusiasm he did (this
also goes into things like trying to instruct and encourage Taarabt and his
other team mates) deserves massive respect, in my opinion. His awareness
of players around him, and of tactical requirements in any given situation, was
far in advance of any other player on the park, as you’d hope from a Premier
League player, and make no mistake, that is what Ghaly is. Anyone who suggests
he’s “Championship at best”, “a donkey”, “liability” and so forth, is simply
wrong.
He should be back in the first team squad. It’s as simple as
that. He has several things that we really lack at the moment, not least some
balls, aggression and ability to put in a tackle in central midfield, and the
confidence and ability to create in the final third.
Anyway, sermon over…on to the rest.
So Taarabt….the guy is an enigma, and right now, I’d be
willing to place a substantial amount of money on him not making it; at least,
not at Spurs. His body language says he doesn’t want to be at this club, and
Clive Allen seems to take some delight in giving him stick from the sidelines,
some of it may be deserved, but it’s pretty clear that this isn’t the coach
that is going to take what talent Taarabt does have and convert him into a
footballer.
As a lone striker, particularly in the first half, he was
hopeless. Failing to retain the ball as it was played into, not by over elaborating,
but just by poor first touch and anticipation. He did look better when Alex
Olsen came on up front and he dropped into a deeper role, and some of his
linking with Ghaly did show promise, but he’s so far from having the tactical
understanding to match the talent that it’s easy to see why he’s still so far
from getting a first team game.
Adam Smith was the youngest player in the starting eleven,
and despite a few lax moments defensively, had a good game. He linked well with
Hutton on the right flank and, once he’s bulked up a bit, could possibly be
regarded as prospect for good things.
Hutton, as per usual, was a good attacking outlet. His
crossing (and general technical ability, as I keep saying) is very good. That
didn’t really tell tonight because there was no real target in the box with
Taarabt as point man, but Hutton remains one of the few players in this group
that you can rely on to consistently beat his man and produce a decent final
ball. As I said, he linked well with Smith and the right flank always looked an
outlet, in contrast to Hughton and Daniels on the left who failed to show any
understanding or consistent threat.
A final mention for Sanchez and Rocha, as the other senior
players on show. Both sought to provide assistance and leadership to the
younger players around them, and whilst neither may have much contribution to
make at first team level this season, they could prove very important in the
development of what talent we do have at reserve level.
The Ratings
Sanchez – 66% - Didn’t have a great deal to do, was unlucky
with the second goal having made two good stops Smith – 73% - Looks quite assured at this level Dervite – 62% - Struggled at times and wasn’t commanding enough Rocha – 66% - Commits himself too early at times, but looks to be
having a positive effect in this group Hughton – 57% - OK defensively, but no offensive
contribution whatsoever Hutton – 74% - Always looks a threat, but no takers for the
service he provides in this kind of system McKenna – 55% - Reasonably disciplined but lacks quality in the
tackle and with the ball at his feet Maghoma – 67% - I’m not a fan, but he did quite well and got
through a decent amount of work box to box Daniels – 61% - Nice goal, but has the physique of a rugby
player and plays football like one Ghaly – 78% - Impressive attitude, work rate and overall
contribution Taarabt – 68% - Still a work in progress, and sadly it seems
like work that only has a chance of being completed at another club
|
-
Spurs Reserves 3-2 West Brom
Reserves
Line up/formation (ages in brackets):
-------------------------------Alnwick (21)-----------------------------
Hughton (19)-----Dervite (20)-----Rocha (29)-----Berchiche (18)
Fraser-Allen (18)---Maghoma (20)---Hutchins (18)---Hutton
(18)
---------------------------------Rose(18)--------------------------------
-------------------------------Barcham(21)-----------------------------
Subs: Button (19) Mtandari (18) Smith (17) Olsen (18)
Townsend (17)
Scorers: Hutchins, Hutton, Barcham
The Game
The reserves kicked off their campaign against West Brom on Monday night with a side shorn of several
key players from last season’s team. Last year’s reserve captain, and one of the
its most impressive performers, defender Troy Archibald-Henville is on loan at
Norwich, striker Tomas Pekhart is on loan at Southampton and midfielder Jake Livermore
is preparing for a career in lower league football at Crewe. The enigmatically
talented Adel Taarabt was absent, possibly on account of the game being played
on the evening of transfer deadline day and the possibility of a last minute loan deal, which may explain why others, such as
Paul Stalteri and Kevin Prince Boateng, were also missing. The other notable
absentee was John Bostock, brought in from Cyrstal Palace
this summer and earmarked as one of the brightest English prospects around,
who is on international duty with the England U17s at the moment.
The first half performance from a somewhat youthful side was
patchy, in what was shaping up to be a rather dull encounter. Most of the
chances fell to West Brom, with Dervite and
Rocha struggling to deal with Roman Bednar’s physical presence. Thankfully,
Spurs picked up their game when play resumed after half time. It wasn’t classic
stuff, but by reserve standards they passed the ball around quite nicely on the
deck, in stark contrast to the hopeless channel punts that seemed to be the
limit of Spurs’ creative invention in the first period.
All three goals were a result of the improved passing and
movement (Hutton’s goal from the penalty spot was won following one of the best
moves of the game), but the win did flatter Spurs somewhat and was aided in no
small part by the dismissal of WBA’s Hancox
for deliberate handball for the penalty. Still, Spurs did demonstrate a decent capability of seeing the game out through possession play following their third goal, which does beg the question as to why Clive Allen doesn't implement a much more cultured style of play generally, particularly given that it would surely be more in line with the first team's game.
The players
In keeping with last season’s trends, two of Spurs’ best
performers came as no surprise - David Hutton and Danny Rose. Hutton, in many respects a classic winger,
has always impressed me, as a player with very good technique – excellent first
touch and adept at going on and crossing with either foot – good pace and
decent ability to go past players. His physique is what makes me think that he
will struggle to make the step up to the first team.
The much hyped Rose was crucial in Spurs turning the
game around. This is probably the first time I’ve really been impressed by him for the reserves.
Due in no small part, I’d wager, to him being played in what is surely a far
more suitable position – in the hole as a second striker – rather than the
central midfield role he occupied for much of last season. His passing was
good, he was aggressive in winning the ball back in all areas of the pitch (he
also seems to have bulked up a little since last season) willing to run with
the ball and quite mature in his decision making when he did get the ball in
and around the box. I don’t think he’s ready for the first team, but he did look
a class above most of the other players on the field at times.
There was also a first glimpse of Yuri Berchiche. It had
looked like he may be on his way back to Spain this summer, but the club
have managed to retain him, and it was easy to see why they would be keen to do
so. Whilst looking a little naïve defensively, he was virtually the only decent
attacking outlet, other than Hutton, during the first half. He looked very
willing to overlap, and confident and comfortable in possession in advanced
areas. It doesn’t look like he will struggle to make the step up to reserve
level, so should feature frequently this season.
The revelation of the game though, for me, was Danny
Hutchins. A player I’d not seen before, he played in the holding role and, for
a player who has apparently been used largely as a utility player at youth
level, showed a very good understanding of the position and reading of the game
in general. He scored an excellently taken goal, breaking forward and lobbing
the keeper, but had already done enough up until that point to impress me. He
was very composed on the ball, never rushed into rash passes and showed good
pass selection when he did release it. Very much a ‘head up’ player, which seems
to be something of a rarity in the reserve players, particularly in midfield. One to keep an eye on at this level over the course of the season.
The other player that, I suppose, most will be interested in
is Dorian Dervite. Unfortunately, it’s hard to take many positives on this
occasion. He struggled with Bednar and also with the pace of some of West Brom’s other attacking players. He looks quite
cumbersome at times and was beaten to the ball far too easily on several
occasions. I know there have been some doubts about his progress following his
serious knee injury, and I have to say those doubts seem justified on this
performance.
As far as most of the others go, it’s the same story as last
season really – far too many sub-standard players who are never going to get
anywhere near the first team at Spurs, and in many cases, I suspect, will
struggle enough to make a pro career for themselves even at lower league level. There are some
supposedly highly rated younger players not getting many chances at reserve
level yet as a result, like Adam Smith (an uneventful cameo here) and the unused Andros Townsend,
and personally, I’d rather see them being blooded at this level than more distinctly
average performances from last year’s misfits. The club have wisely cleared a
few out over the summer, either permanently or on loan deals, but haven’t
really gone far enough, in my opinion.
The Ratings
Alnwick 57% – Didn’t do much wrong, but looks far from
Premier League level
Hughton 52% – Struggled in either full back position
Berchiche 63% – Always a willing outlet but must improve
defensively
Hutchins – 81% – Good contribution both offensively and
defensively
Dervite – 56% – Struggled to contain West
Brom forwards
Rocha – 53% – Wasn’t having a great game when he departed at
half time
Fraser-Allen – 55% – Solitary moment of productivity created
the winning goal
Maghoma – 51% – Lacking in any quality
Barcham – 61% – Willing and hard working but extremely
limited
Rose – 80% – Recovered from a quiet first half to influence
proceedings in the second
Hutton – 72% – Always looked a threat, but needed more of
the ball
|
|
|
|